Business franchises have emerged as a prevalent and effective strategy for business expansion, offering entrepreneurs the opportunity to own and operate under an established brand, product, or service. Through franchise systems, companies can rapidly expand their market presence, tap into local markets, and boost revenue streams. However, like any intricate business arrangement, franchise systems are susceptible to conflicts. Understanding the dynamics of conflict within these systems is vital for preserving relationship harmony, safeguarding brand integrity, and ensuring long-term success. These conflicts, whether temporary, permanent, or imagined, are inherent to business franchise systems.
The Franchise Relationship
The foundation of a franchise system is the relationship between the franchisor and the franchisee. A franchisor is the owner of the business, while the franchisee is an independent operator who licenses the right to use the franchisor’s brand, products, and services. This relationship is contractual and legally binding, outlining the rights, responsibilities, and obligations of both parties. Conflicts often emerge when expectations and realities within this relationship diverge. However, franchise relationships need be underpinned with regular consistent communication to reduce harmful effects of franchise conflict. Conflict is inevitable in a Franchise System and its needs to be managed before it escalates and impacts the franchise systems efficiency and harms relationships.
1. Divergent Expectations
Franchisees enter into an agreement with certain expectations. They anticipate receiving the necessary support, training, and resources from the franchisor to ensure the success of their business. Meanwhile, franchisors expect franchisees to operate according to their established standards and protect their brand’s reputation. When these expectations are not met, it can lead to disputes and conflicts.
2. Asymmetrical Power
The franchisor-franchisee relationship often involves a significant power imbalance. The franchisor usually holds more power because they control the brand and the franchise system. This power dynamic can lead to conflicts when franchisees feel unheard, undervalued, or unfairly treated by the franchisor.
Sources of Conflict in Franchise Systems
Understanding the sources of conflict within franchise systems is vital for addressing and preventing disputes effectively. These conflicts can emerge from various areas:
1. Contractual Disagreements
The franchise agreement is the cornerstone of the relationship between the franchisor and franchisee. Permanent conflicts may arise if the contract is not clear, if either party breaches its terms, or if there are ambiguities and misunderstandings within the agreement. Contractual disagreements can pertain to issues such as royalty fees, territory rights, and renewal terms.
2. Quality Control and Brand Standards
One of the main attractions of franchising is the consistent brand experience that consumers expect. Temporary and permanent conflicts can arise when franchisees deviate from the franchisor’s brand standards or when franchisees believe that these standards are too stringent and costly to maintain. Striking a balance between uniformity and flexibility is a challenge for both parties.
3. Territory and Market Conflicts
Franchisees often operate in exclusive territories, and permanent conflicts can arise when territorial boundaries overlap or when franchisees feel that the franchisor is not adequately protecting their exclusive rights. Market competition can also lead to disputes when multiple franchisees are vying for the same customer base.
4. Operational and Training Issues
Franchisees require proper training and operational support to effectively run their businesses. Temporary conflicts can emerge when franchisees believe that the franchisor is not delivering on its promises regarding training, marketing support, or product quality.
5. Change Management
Adapting to change is a significant source of temporary conflict in franchise systems. When the franchisor introduces new products, marketing strategies, or operational procedures, franchisees may resist these changes, believing that they will negatively impact their businesses. Managing and communicating these changes and ensuring franchisee buy-in is a delicate balancing act.
6. Favouring one Franchisee over another
Sometimes conflict can be an be an imaginary conflict. This can be when; a franchisee perceives that the franchisor is intentionally favouring other franchise locations over theirs in terms of promotional support and marketing resources. Despite evidence suggesting equal treatment among all franchisees, the franchisee harbours a belief that they are being unfairly disadvantaged.
Conflict Resolution and Prevention
Resolving conflicts and preventing them from escalating is essential for maintaining the stability and success of franchise systems. Here are some strategies for both franchisors and franchisees:
1. Clear and Comprehensive Contracts
Thoroughly drafted franchise agreements that clearly outline the rights, responsibilities, and expectations of both parties are crucial. Legal counsel experienced in franchise law should review these contracts to ensure they are fair, equitable, and devoid of ambiguities.
2. Effective Communication
Open and transparent communication between franchisors and franchisees is key to preventing and resolving conflicts. Regular meetings, feedback channels, and grievance mechanisms can help identify and address issues in their early stages.
3. Training and Support
Franchisors should provide comprehensive training programs and ongoing support to help franchisees succeed. A well-trained franchisee is more likely to meet brand standards and operate successfully. Adequate support can also prevent conflicts stemming from operational issues.
4. Mediation and Arbitration
In the event of a dispute, mediation and arbitration can be valuable tools for conflict resolution. Including dispute resolution mechanisms in the franchise agreement can help both parties address issues without resorting to costly and time-consuming legal battles.
5. Ongoing Relationship Building
Franchise relationships should be viewed as partnerships. Building and nurturing these relationships over time can foster mutual trust and understanding, making it easier to resolve conflicts when they arise.
The Role of Technology in Conflict Management
Modern technology has had a significant impact on how franchise systems manage conflicts. Tools such as customer relationship management (CRM) software, social media monitoring, and online communication platforms allow franchisors to stay connected with their franchisees and consumers. By leveraging these technologies, franchisors can promptly address emerging issues, provide support, and gain insights into customer experiences.
Additionally, technology can help streamline the franchise management process, reducing potential sources of conflict. Centralised systems for ordering supplies, managing inventory, and tracking financial transactions can improve operational efficiency and minimize disputes related to orders, deliveries, and finances.
Case Studies: Franchisee Conflicts
McDonald’s: McDonald’s, one of the world’s largest fast-food chains, has faced various conflicts with its franchisees over the years. These conflicts have ranged from disputes over menu changes and pricing strategies to concerns about restaurant remodelling requirements and operational expenses. Franchisees have sometimes accused the company of implementing policies that prioritize corporate profits over the interests of individual franchise owners.
Subway: Subway, known for its submarine sandwiches, has experienced conflicts with franchisees regarding issues such as royalty fees, advertising expenditures, and store profitability. Franchisees have raised concerns about the company’s handling of franchisee-owned restaurants, particularly regarding support, marketing initiatives, and product quality standards. In some instances, franchisees have taken legal action against Subway over alleged unfair business practices.
Dunkin’: Dunkin’, the popular coffee and doughnut chain, has encountered conflicts with franchisees related to store remodelling mandates, product pricing, and supply chain issues. Franchisees have criticized the company’s directives regarding store upgrades and have expressed frustration over perceived lack of transparency in decision-making processes. Additionally, disputes have arisen over the allocation of advertising funds and the impact of corporate policies on franchisee profitability.
To conclude, understanding the dynamics of conflict within business franchise systems is essential for franchisors and franchisees to maintain strong, successful partnerships. By recognising the sources of conflict and implementing effective conflict resolution and prevention strategies, these relationships can thrive and continue to contribute to the growth and success of the franchise business model. Furthermore, leveraging technology to facilitate communication, streamline operations, and gather data is increasingly important in managing and preventing conflicts within franchise systems. Ultimately, fostering a culture of cooperation, trust, and transparency between franchisors and franchisees is key to long-term success in the world of franchising.
Dr. Nigel Bairstow is an academic practitioner with experience working in a variety of marketing roles for large multinational companies such as Alcan Aluminium, Komatsu, Atlas Copco, and 3M. He completed his PhD in Marketing in 2012. His research focus is on B2B and B2B marketing channels.
UTS is the top-ranked young university in Australia. Our vision is to be a leading public university of technology recognised for our global impact. We’re known for our innovative teaching. We’re committed to practical innovation and research that benefits industry and society. We believe in social change to create a more just and equal world.